Nicaragua vs Dominican Cigar Duo Sampler
Two strongest New World origins, head to head
Nicaragua vs Dominican Duo pairs the Plasencia Alma del Cielo Celeste Robusto with the Arturo Fuente Don Carlos Robusto, two of the strongest expressions from the two New World origins that define modern cigar making. Plasencia's high altitude Nicaraguan puro brings marzipan, honey and ginger spice, while Fuente's benchmark Dominican brings dark cedar, dried fruit and espresso.
Same medium to full strength, two completely different countries. A head to head rather than a full sampler, for anyone who wants to taste the difference between Nicaragua and the Dominican Republic without committing to a bigger box.
What's Inside: Plasencia Alma del Cielo Celeste Robusto — Arturo Fuente Don Carlos Robusto Cigar
Brand: Plasencia & Arturo Fuente
Origin: Nicaragua & Dominican Republic
Contents: 1 x Plasencia Alma del Cielo Celeste Robusto (4 7/8" x 52), 1 x Arturo Fuente Don Carlos Robusto
Wrapper, binder, filler:
- Plasencia Alma del Cielo Celeste Robusto: Nicaraguan wrapper, Nicaraguan binder, Nicaraguan filler (true puro)
- Arturo Fuente Don Carlos Robusto: African Cameroon wrapper over aged Dominican tobacco.
Strength: Medium to full across the set
Enjoyment time: 45 to 60 minutes depending on the cigar
Packaging: 2-cigar curated comparison set
Two of the strongest New World origins, side by side rather than blended into a bigger set.
Plasencia Alma del Cielo Celeste Robusto (4 7/8" x 52): A true Nicaraguan puro grown at 1,300 metres on the Plasencia family's Finca San Julian estate. Marzipan and honey open the smoke, nougat and orange zest lift the middle, and a precise ginger spice ties the finish together. Medium strength, around 45 minutes.
Arturo Fuente Don Carlos Robusto: A benchmark medium-to-full-bodied Dominican, sitting at the pinnacle of the Fuente portfolio. Opens with dark cedar and dried fruit, deepening into espresso and a long, warm finish.
Recommended order: Plasencia Alma del Cielo Celeste Robusto first, since its medium body and brighter fruit notes are easier to place before stepping up to the Arturo Fuente Don Carlos Robusto, the fuller and more intense of the two.
Heritage: Plasencia has grown tobacco across Nicaragua and Honduras since 1865, with this puro's filler coming from the family's Finca San Julian estate. Arturo Fuente is a multi-generational Dominican house, and the Don Carlos line was created in honour of Don Carlos Fuente Sr., representing the pinnacle of the family's craft.
Tasting Notes
Two profiles from the two New World origins that anchor the range:
- Plasencia Alma del Cielo Celeste Robusto: Sweet notes, Cedar notes, Spice notes
- Arturo Fuente Don Carlos Robusto: Cedar notes, Sweet notes, Coffee notes
Cigar Pairing Notes
A good spirit ties both together, an aged rum or whisky for the Plasencia's marzipan and honey, an aged bourbon or XO Cognac for the Fuente's espresso finish. Something off the grill gives both cigars enough weight to stand up to.
Drink pairing: Spirits
Food pairing: Meat
- 1 x Plasencia Alma del Cielo Celeste Robusto — 4 7/8" x 52 — ~45 min
- 1 x Arturo Fuente Don Carlos Robusto Cigar — Robusto — ~50 to 60 min (est.)
Every Toro Puro order arrives in the same considered way, the same box, the same care, the same attention to the moment you are about to have.
See how your order arrives →
Free returns on non-cigar products within 14 days. If you’re not satisfied with your purchase, simply contact us and we’ll assist with the return. See our Returns and Refund Policcy for details.
Cigars and pipe tobacco contain tobacco. Smoking is harmful to your health and that of those around you. Smoking causes cancer, heart disease, and respiratory illness. For support and guidance, visit the NHS Stop Smoking Service.
AT YOUR SERVICE

Free delivery on orders over £75 | T&C apply
FAQ
Toro Puro offers a worry-free shopping experienceEach order, whether it includes cigars or accessories, undergoes meticulous handling. Our team hand-picks every cigar, ensuring they are in optimal condition before they reach you. Additionally, cigars are individually checked to ensure they meet our high standards.
Accessories also undergo thorough quality checks to ensure they are in perfect condition.
Furthermore, all cigars are carefully packed, sealed in humidity packs, and cigar boxes are accompanied by Boveda packs, guaranteeing that your items arrive in pristine condition.
How much is delivery?Orders of £75 or more enjoy free shipping across the UK. Orders under £75 incur a £9.99 shipping fee.
We’re dedicated to promptly delivering all orders, big or small, right to your doorstep.
Link to your shipping policy.
When will my order be delivered?Orders are processed promptly within 24 hours on weekdays, excluding weekends, ensuring a prompt start to your delivery journey.
We ship your orders via APC 24h tracked delivery service, ensuring the secure and reliable transportation of your items.
Regardless of your order size, rest assured that your package will be swiftly and securely delivered right to your doorstep, providing peace of mind every step of the way.
THE TORO PURO CLUB
Early access to limited cigars, first sight of event tickets, and £15 off your first order over £150. By signing up, you agree to our Privacy Policy*